Slutrapportering. Projekttitel: Green It Homes

Transkript

1 #$%&'()*+,-./(/.0(1$2344%2'(5'%$&)(6/%%+)77/8981$93%.$*+4896,2/,,)75($$9:;<)7$, ($1/96$9)72'(1)*B7/9+/9938,%044$%2)+3,$(/>-/%%391$(,'+//9.091/(9/,>(/+%8,+/($/+%8)9 Rapportering och Information 90(/($4/%8)97$1($4$./9%/($1/+%8)9$()*B2'(,$1$,,/7$1($1/+%8)9$44/%$I%$(/.,-B'6+./48%J Slutrapportering 1$%%/,0%%+/97/92)(734$(//(%8+4/(,,)7+/9%=09/,)7892)(7/%8)9)*B3>>4?,9896% $(D Projekttitel: Green It Homes Bilder Ett forsknings- och utvecklingsprojekt delfinansierat av Göteborg Forskningsstiftelse "

2 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Abstract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

3 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) "#$%&'$()))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))(* +&,,&-.&$$-/-0()))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))( /-0()))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))(6 7%44-(28(9:,4#(/(4$$(#$;%%4(#&,,&-<&-0())))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))(=( GE'5D/8(1(6-'488+'0%' ->?-5&%0%?-##-/$$(7%44-(28(9:,4#())))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))(BC D4,:-#$%&$/:-#&-3?00-/-0&%(.;%(7%44-(2$(9:,4#(E%:$:$FE()))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))(B= "#$%&##'()&*)$&+',*&&%'-.'/01&#'2&%34$#56())))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))(1A S

4 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Sammanfattning 1&E0%3+'6+2$"1L+'6MAG1(.4(5C &'%%()#*+,%-$4'6%(+,<E'0-1(+,'4,%(<E')((+9401+(-8.400<+',%(&)#*C %(014.1F(6.4(5AK9%'16%+2$G1(.4(5CF(6.4(5$4'1546%00<E'M.5'40%.(U0,%(<'M( ">P>8M6M'%(/88'/-0(1(6CHM)WX&$4'-1(4'E00%'1F(6.4(5U'<E'$+88(1(6%( T

5 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) V4'0(%'- c%61(-+,u'%(1(0%'(401+(%..$m'594'/.%9%'4(0e'a5%004-4,4'3%0%$4'913%5e,0-+, *U'(U b

6 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 8G?-#$( o o o K4,,4(<400(1(649&'%%()#*+,%-18/(@0<+', 7%44-(28(9:,4#(?%(/5&0(4-(@-/H(.G?%%>?%,4I43($G?-#$IE%:5@H$(#:,(>/#&%($:$&3( 4-4%0/-(.;%(&->?-5&%-&)( 7%44-(28(9:,4#(04%(&->?-5&%4-(,;G3/0<4$(&$$(.;3G&J(#$F%&(:'<(.;%@$#EK( 4-4%0/.;%"%@H-/-04-(/(.&#$/0<4$4-(,45(-K0%&(4-H3&(-F'H43$&3( 7%44-(28(9:,4#(#H&E&%(.;%(7;$4":%0(L-4%0/(4-(,;G3/0<4$(&$$(@$>4'H3&(#/-( $G?-#$4E:%$.;3G(#:,(4$$(H:,E34,4-$(,:$(43M#/5&-J(#&,$(>/5&%4@$>4'H3&(.G?%%>?%,4#/5&-)(( D4,:-#$%&$/:-( o N(7%44-(28(9:,4#(E%:$:$FE4%(<&%(/-#$&334%&#(:'<($4#$&$#(@%(4$$(&->?-5&%M(:'<( $4H-/HE4%#E4H$/>J(,45(0:5&(%4#@3$&$( 84H-/H( o o 2(E%:G4H$4$(<&%(<K%5>&%&(:'<(,G@H>&%&(@EE0%&54%&$#(4334%("F$$#(@$(.;%(&$$(;H&( %:"@#$<4$4-( L-(E3&-(.;%(F$$4%3/0&%4(@EE5&$4%/-0&%(<&%(#H&E&$#J(,45(,K3(.;%(&$$(-K(4-(%:"@#$( /--:>&$/>(E%:5@H$(.;%(,&%H-&54-( O&%H-&5( o 2(E%:G4H$4$(<&%(54$(>4%/./4%&$#(&$$(7;$4":%0(L-4%0/(<&%('&(A*(CCC(3?,E3/0&(H@-54%( /-:,(7;$4":%0#%40/:-4-)(74-:,(D/-(L3(./--#(54$(4-(E:$4-$/&3(&$$(-K(H3/4-$4%(/( <43&(+>4%/04)( +&,&%"4$4-(( o 74-:,(E%:G4H$4$(<&%(7%44-(28(9:,4#(H:-#:%$/4$(.K$$(,;G3/0<4$4-(&$$(G:""&(-?%&( $4H-/H4%(:'<(&..?%#@$>4'H3&%4(/-:,(7;$4":%0(L-4%0/J(>/3H4$(#$?%H$(:'<(#$;$$&$( E%:G4H$4$)(( o +&,&%"4$4-(,45(P40/-(#&,$(O&/-7&$4J(<K%5>&%@":3&0(%4#E4H$/>4(28M #$%@H$@%":3&0(<&%(4$&"34%&$#J(>/3H4$(,;G3/00;%(4-(,;G3/0(.%&,$/5(,&%H-&5#/-$%:5@H$/:-)( g

7 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Inledning ">>I$45%)WX&-+,700%'-04(-94'160<E'&'%%()#*+,%-%(075.16,M.31.5+,945-+, &++6.%AF`YAW41(&40%A#%(5'1.A^aF(%'67A&FAK+(7F'12--+(A+2$,M(64<.%'+<<121% (10U9.1(6%(+,4(9U(54'(4-6/(-0C^0E9%'5%0045'19%'3.C4CF^%(' $%,4/0+,401+(-3+.46%0c%61(AW41(640%+2$%00<.%' $%''4'C&)#*$4'1(0%34'4 J

8 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 34-%'4-5%.-8M%Q8%'01-%(-/0.M04(5%(+2$5%.-8M4(9U(54'(4-/88.%9%.-%'Cd191..U9%( +2$1(0%,1(-010%Q0%((%54(-+,8.42%'4'&'%%()#*+,%-1%00-0E''%-4,,4($4(6,%("#$%&$%'('))(*+,%'('&('**$-$*(.%(/*012$*)1$33'(45(1*)$(0+%(#6%12'#7(( <E.D4,%58M5%((4'%-4C Green IT Homes i ett större sammanhang 5%004U' (@+,8.%00%'4(5%@/(5<E'5%.4'-+,%Q%,8%.91--U@%'$%0-.E-(1(64' E-(1(6%(CH%0<1((-+<04-01(64(40/'.164'%.401+(%' '%8M%<0%'-+, 5%(015164'%'%.401+(%(94'%(.%9%'4(0E'-'%.401+(5M@/(5%(+<043%0'4@04' %(%'61%<<%@0191-%'1(6-+,%(%(6M(6-4@01910%091.@%01((%3U'400,4(1(0%-@4<<4'-16 (M6+('%.401+(01..-1(%<<%@0191-%'1(6-.%9%'4(0E'Z-4, ,,4(3%$M..%'-1( '%.401+(01..%(%'61.%9%'4(0E'%([ _@0E'-6'/88%(@'1(6&'%%()#*+,%-$4'1G+^8'+D%@0%0/0E@40-+2$-0U'@0-+2$ 1((%$M..%'15463M5%<.%'40%@(1@3+.46-M-+,W41(640%+2$c%61(A-M9U.-+,4(5'4 1(0%'(401+(%..44@0E'%'8M0%@(1@-154(A%Q%,8%.91-X/''%(0X+-0C W%'-8%21<1@0$4'911(+,&'%%()#*+,%-;8'+D%@ /0<+'-@45%.4'49+,'M5%0 %(%'61%<<%@0191-%'1(613766(45%'e Energistyrningstjänster för extern partner &%(+,400@+88.4/88$/-%(,+0%(6%,%(-4,-%'9%'91.@%(</(6%'4'-+,,+0+'1-7-0%,%0@4(,4(8M%00'401+(%..0-U00-@484<E'/0-U00(1(64'<E'%(%Q0%'(84'0(%'400 %'3D/54-07'(1(649%(%'614(9U(5(1(6%(15%4(-./0(43766(45%'(4CW4'@(45%( 3%(U,(%'5% (-+2$5%01((%3U'15%004< %4(-./0(4%(%'614(9U(54'(4 01..M0%'4005%(%Q0%'(484'0(%'(@+'094'160-U(@%'%(%'6101..<E'-%.( %,%0C i

9 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Fjärrvärmestyrning 1(51915/%..4<DU''9U',%9UQ.4'%(CH%0$4'/88-0M00%( <E'5%.4'<E'%(%' %(C Mobil styrning/prognos/övervakning för närmare kundrelation I

10 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) </(6%'403'4+2$,1(5'%3'4A ,,44(5449-0U(516<E'3U00'1(6-+,6%(+,-7'40 -9M'05% '4400<M/0 4(9U(534'45404<'M(3766(45%'(4- %.2%(0'4.%'+2$<DU''9U',%2%(0'4.%' +2$91-%'<'4,%,+04001(+,%( 1( (%'1-4,34(5,%5 Hur plattformen planerar att arbeta vidare med resultatet av FoU projektet 8%9$/)(09.%%#:*( #1..-4,,4(-,%5)(0%'42019% ;**$%#)'2$*(<=)$"%,( @E8,4((4<E'3/(5%0+2$&E0%3+'6- P>

11 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 24<]%'-4,0">>0DU(-0%<E'%046+2$1(0'%--%+'64(1-401+(%'CH%-%'&'%%()#*+,%--+, >.#)#&$%1,$e^(5%'">PP$4'&'%%()#*+,%-%043.%'40IJ c%54((/<1((-5%0%00-0+'01(0'%--% <'M(9%,f400<M045%.49'%-/.040%( <'M(5%--4CdU-0'4&E04.4(5-'%61+(%(-,1.DE(U,( E5D4 +2$400-4,4'3%0%,%5%(%' CDEe&'%%()#*+,%-$4'<E'% a4.1<+'(1%(A^K_CH%0<1((-%00-0+'01(0'%--%<E' -,M$/-<4-016$%0%'C PP

12 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 3M5% (45%',%59U',%-7-0%,-+,$U,04'9U',%<'M(9U',%8/,8-M9U.-+, <'M(<DU''9U',%4(-./0(1(6C Vad pengarna har använts till @4( '+3.%,C EL(J(;*#)'33')1*(1(IM(0'#)1,5$)$%KH%--4P><4-016$%0%'/06E'6'/(5%(01.. 9%'1<1%'1(64'(4CG4-016$%0%'(4$4'94.0-/01-4,4'3%0%,%551-0'13/0E'%'(4C 0DU(-0%'(4C ES(J(E*&.*2'%&$%101$%1*,('&()9.*#)$%(1('6631/')1*$*KV %,%0$4'%( /88-U00(1(60DU(-0%'-+, '%4(9U(54'6'/88%'C*/'$4'5%--4</(6%'40+2$ '+3/-0$%01-7-0%,%0C P"

13 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) EV(J(C)&$4/31*,('&(#$%&$%63'))0%O()133('))(,$(5$35$)#6$%#6$/)1&W&E0%3+'6%(%'61U' %(%'614(9U(54'(4-X4'3+(<++08'1(0C ( PS

14 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Använbarhetsutvärdering Green IT Homes Sammanfattning K7<0%0,%5'488+'0%(U'400'%5+91-4'%-/.0405%.-<'M(%(%Q8%'0/09U'5%'1(6495%(,+31.48'+0+078%(B&'%%()#*+,%-BZ&)#*[+2$5%.-<'M(1(0%'9D/%',%50%-04(9U(54'% 6D+'5%-6%(+,1(0%'9D/%',%5T0%-04(9U(54'%CK7<0%094'400<M%(31.549$/'5% /88.%95%4(9U(5(1(6%(49&)#*;8'+0+078%(CKM9U.%Q8%'0/09U'5%'1(6%(-+,1(0%'9D/; 4(9U(54'%3%'E'-496'U(--(100%0-/0<+',(1(6C)(3.4(5(1(6498'+<%--1+(%.. Inledning '%-8+(-+2$%(%' %(-,ED.16$%0%'01..(740DU(-0%'+2$5%.-/09U'5%'4-7-0%,%0- '+3/-0$%0+2$/886'45%'1(6-,ED.16$%0%'BCH%((4'488+'01(6M'15%(<E'-045%.%(49 PT

15 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 8'+0+078;6'U(--(100%0<E'&'%%()#*+,%-Z&)#*[-4,0%(-4,,4(-0U..(1(649 E%:G4H$4$(7%44-(28(9:,4#(*S(T7%44-(28(9:,4#(R(U:2(&-#;H&-(.%K-(2OV7(,45( V)\)(:'<(\/,J(D)X)([*CAA])((,4$&M&-&3F$/'&3(%4>/4Y(:.(L,E/%/'&3(O:"/34(^#&"/3/$F( Effektmål 1 Via mobil klient kunna ta del av det egna hushållets momentana energiförbrukning Effektmål 2 Via mobil klient kunna styra hemmet avseende inomhusklimat samt enskild apparat Effektmål 3 l@45,%59%0%($%0$+-4(9u(54'%-@4.%5401..,1(-@45%(%'61<e'3'/@(1(61$%,,%0 H%--4%<<%@0,M.U'496E'4(5%1/09U'5%'1(6%(498'+0+078%(-+,/06M'<'M(5%--4,M.C Pb

16 Expert-utvärdering av användbarhet FQ8%'0;/09U'5%'1(6%(498'+0+078%(-4(9U(534'$%06%(+,<E'-8M5%(1V$+(%;488<E' Metodik Användbarhetsprinciper och mål för applikationens användning 02;3CYM6'46%(%'%..48'1(218%'<E'%004(9U(534'0,+31.06'U(--(100U'Z-%0%QX+/-4'1- %04.[e >/5&%4)( 8/33.%45##$?3343#4)(->?-5&%4-(H?--4%(#/0(-;G5(,45(&->?-5-/-04-(&>($/33?,E-/-04-)(( :'<(>&5(<:-I<&-(#G?3>(H&-(0;%&(.;%(&$$(K$0?%5&(.434$)(->?-5&%4-(";%(:'H#K(.K( W?%"&%<4$)(8/33?,E-/-04-(#H&(>&%&(4-H43(&$$(3?%&(#/0)(L-H43<4$(?%(4-(345#$G?%-&(.;%( "4<;>&(3?%&(:,)(D4$(#H&(:'H#K(>&%&(4-H43$(&$$(,/--&#(:3/H&(/H:-4%#("4$F543#4(:'<(/(

17 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) `F$$&)(D4$$&(?%(4-(&#E4H$(#:,("4#$?,#(&>(#F#$4,4$#I&EE3/H&$/:-4-#IE%:0%&,,4$#( Målgrupper för prototypen 1. Den ekonomiske villaägaren 2. Den miljömedvetna lägenhetsinnehavaren 3. Den Pryltokiga WM.+2$5%-16(M06U'5%'M0%'6%-1<16/'PZ$U,045<'M(8-9-%&7-"):)02;3[C)5%((4 /09U'5%'1(6$4'91/06M00<'M(,M.6'/88P+2$"C PJ

18 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Mål för användning uttryckta i projekt-ansökan _(9U(54'%(-@4@/((4e D$(45(0=%#)+-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6 o GE'-0M-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(61'%4.015 o GE'-0M-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(61'%4.0159U60,+0@+-0(45%' Pi

19 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) o GE'-0M-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(61'%4.0159U60,+0B24'3+(<++08'1(0-B o GE'-0M-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(61'%4.0159U60,+0.%9(45-@94.10%0 D1OQ3$%'-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6 D):%'-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6 o VM%00%(@%.0-U00E9%'94@4-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6+2$-07'45%(-4,,4 +3%'+%(5%4994',4(3%<1((%'-16 o #1..$4(54$M..48'+6'4,,%5%(%'61'%.40%'45%-07'(1(6-,ED.16$%0%' )(<+',401+(-+,6%'4(9U(54'%(,ED.16$%04006E'4%004@0190%(%'6194. o -4,,4(<E'0C%QC0%,8%'40/'A9%( (+2$0%,8%'40/'0+.%'4(-%' mm0%'4(9u(54'%('% (/.u6%$ed4+2$,1(-@4-100/o0%)3.,$ Antaganden om användargrupp )(6%(5%04.D%'451(<+',401+(+,91.@%(4(9U(54';6'/88&)#*;488%(9U(5%' <1(( MC`,5%(4(9U(54'6'/88-+,$4'<M000%-04488%($4''%@'70%'40-<E'40094'4 '%8'%-%(04019<E'01..0U(@04(9U(54'6'/88U'5%0%('% %6'U(-456'/88-+,49-%-e <="#$7>"6&6-$/-$M..94'-,%5.%,,4'U'-1?&?-%&6-1-1(%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6+2$$4'%( '%.40190@+?)>1.(45$CH%U'5%--/0+,59-15.*+66&A#$&1)5A17&%$)*#1.$>(15@>16-%+2$U' 9&1&)2;B&19=16&%-C 9@#<K33( ^$"/35-/-0#-/>K( b%h4( c354%(r(>@d-&(/(<@#<k334$(( 2-H3@54%&#(#F-#H&5&54e(U?%0"3/-5&e(f35%4([;>4%(_g(K%]e( L%.&%-&(#,&%$ME<:-4#M&->?-5&%4e( Antaganden om miljö för användning a:#$&54-(r(3?04-<4$(4334%(>/33&( QK(5/#$&-#(.%K-($(4d(&%"4$#E3&$#4-( Z&%5&0##/$@&$/:-4%( ->?-5-/-0(H&-("3/(&>"%@$4-( WG@#M(:'<(3G@5.;%<K33&-54-(H&-(>&%/4%&( ->?-5-/-0(.;%(/-5/>/54%(#K>?3(#:,(/(#&,&%"4$4e( PI

20 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Appen Green IT Homes 1(0%/09U'5%'40-C "#$"%&' o h&$$( o \%( o Vi*( \:,.:%$3?04#>?3G&%4(R(/-#$&334%&54#(B(5&0&%(/--&-(/-$4%>G@4%-&(0G:%54#)(( O;G3/0<4$($/33(&->?-5&%<G?3EI.;%H3&%/-0&%(./--#(04-:,(T/T( O4-F%&5(3?-0#$(-45(EK(#$&%$>F-S( o +$&%$(R(D4-(;>4%#$&( o 9/#$:%/H(R(->?-5&%4-(.;%.3F$$&#($/33(#4E&%&$(>F( o EE&%&$4%(R(LG(/(.@-H$/:-(?-(:'<(@$>?%54%&54#(5?%,45(/-$4)(( o 2-#$?33-/-0&%(R(9?%(#H&(&->?-5&%4-(H@--&(%40/#$%4%&(.34%(?-(4$$(<@#)(U%&,0K%( /-$4(<@%(,K-0&)( ()*"+$),' &%'1(<+',401+(+,0+04.<E'3'/@(1(6A%.<E'3'/@(1(6+2$/889U',(1(6-<E'3'/@(1(6k 4(9U(54'$DU.8-4@(4- +4-&#$4($/,,4-( +4-&#$4(5F0-4$( +4-&#$4(>4'H&-( +4-&#$4(B(,K-&54%-&( +4-&#$4(_(,K-&54%-&( +4-&#$4(K%4$( -..#$#"/$' d7(</(6%'4'1(0%u((/k4(9u(54'$du.8-4@(4-01*"2331)14#$' 8'+6'4,,%0/04(<E'@.4'1( '<E'CG/(@01+(%(<E'@(488%(Bc%516%'4BU'+@.4'CH%0 <'4,6M'1(0%945,4(-@4'%516%'4CH%0U'+2@-M+@.4'0$/',4(9UQ.4',%..4(+.1@ %'C ">

21 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) Vad utvärderas? 8'%21-%'45%-18-9-%&7-"):)02;3+2$3'704(%55%--415%.<'M6+'49-%%(5%488%(&)#*C Frågor i relation till effektmål FQ8%'0/09U'5%'1(6%(-0U..%'<%,<'M6+'1'%.401+(01..5%015164'%(U,(54%<<%@0,M.%(C F<<%@0,M."+2$S$4'5%.40-/888M09M5%.,M.CH%<%,<'M6+'(4U'e A) 2(>/3H4-(@$#$%?'H-/-0(H&-(&->?-5&%4-($&(543(&>(54$(40-&(<@#<K334$#(,:,4-$&-&( 4-4%0/.;%"%@H-/-0e([L..4H$,K3(A]( *) 2(>/3H4-(@$#$%?'H-/-0(H&-(&->?-5&%4-(#$F%&(<4,,4$(&>#44-54(/-:,<@#H3/,&$e( [L..4H$,K3(*&]( B) 2(>/3H4-(@$#$%?'H-/-0(H&-(&->?-5&%4-(#$F%&(<4,,4$(&>#44-54(4-#H/35(&EE&%&$e( [L..4H$,K3(*"]( 1) 2(>/3H4-(@$#$%?'H-/-0(.K%(&->?-5&%4-(4-(;H&5(,45>4$4-<4$(:,(4-4%0/.;%"%@H-/-04-(/( <4,,4$e([L..4H$,K3(B&]( g) 2(>/3H4-(@$#$%?'H-/-0(3454%(&->?-5&%4-#(;H&54(,45>4$4-<4$($/33(,/-#H&5( 4-4%0/.;%"%@H-/-0(/(<4,,4$e([L..4H$,K3(B"]( G'M6+'(4$4'1/09U'5%'1(6%(3%-94'40-6%(+,400-0U..4700%'.164'%<'M6+'01..94'D% %<<%@0,M.-<'M64CH%--4U'91.@45%.4'-+,16'U(--(100%0U'496E'4(5%<E'400,M.%0-@4 /88(M-+2$$/'9U.5%--4-0E5D%',M.%0,%549-%%(5%8M-8%21<12%'45%@'10%'1%'C c%-/.040%(8'%-%(0%'4-6%(+,3%5e,(1(64994'd%5%.<'m64c Resultat expertutvärdering IH -')$4=&%'"9#9*7J=%$%3'=>%'>%)7%G>*&%'9>'G&4'>)'G&9'&3%>'5"#5K44&9#'101&%9>%>' &%&*3$8<*B*"=%$%3L'2M88&=91K4'I6' &) Z/3H&(543&%(/(0%?-##-/$$4$(?%(&>0;%&-54(.;%(&$$(,K34$(#H&(@EE-K#e( O;G3/00;%#(&>(5#""6*)77$#1 8 (/()17+$9#")+1*$:"#1(#:,(3/004%(EK( "#$"*);#1)(L-4%0/.;%"%@H-/-0(H&-(:'H#K(@$$%F'H&#(/(<$(:'<(=>?)(( ") 9@%(>?3(#$;5G4%(54##&(543&%(,K34$(,45(&>#44-54(EK(#E4'/./'4%&54(H%/$4%/4%e( P434>&-$&(H%/$4%/4%S(8/330?-03/0<4$J("40%/E3/0<4$J(3?#"&%<4$( a45;,-/-0s(+/..%:%-&(?%(3?$$&(&$$(3?#&(:'<(?%(3?$$/330?-03/0&(ek( #$&%$,4-F-)(D4$(?%(4-H43$(&$$(.;%#$K(<@%(,&-("F$4%(,433&-(h&$$M #/..%:%-&J(\%(:'<(Vi*)(h&$$M#/..%&-(#K>?3(#:,(\%M#/..%&-(:'<(Vi*(.3@H$@4%&%(<43&($/54-(:'<(54--&(.445"&'H(?%(#>K%(&$$($:3H&)(D4$(H&-( "4%:(EK(&$$(54-(.&H$/#H&(.;%"%@H-/-04-(.3@H$@4%&%J(,4-(54$$&(H&-(,&-( A (7%?-##-/$$4$#(H:,E:-4-$4%(&-04#(/(.4$#$/3( "P

22 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) -K0%&(>?%54-(&$$(G?,.;%&(,45)(Vi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l>4%#$(ek("/354-(./--#(4-(3/#$(,45(>&34-(tc&41tj(tda1#;t(:'<(te$t)( ") P434>&-$&(H%/$4%/4%S(8/330?-03/0<4$J("40%/E3/0<4$J(3?#"&%<4$J(-F$$&( &$$(>?3G&(:3/H&(3?04-(04-:,(&$$(>?3G&(F(4334%(6)(`?%(&->?-5&%4-(?-5%&%( ""

23 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) ') :'<(E4%(K%("3/%(54$(4-(#H/33-&5(EK(-?#$&-(gCCC(H%)( B) -')$4=&%'"9#9*7J=%$%3'=>%'>%)7%G>*&%'#9E*>'5&11&9'>)#&&%G&'&%#=$4G'>NN>*>9L' /-$4(>&%(/,E34,4-$4%&5(/(&EE4-)( &) 2H:-4-(T-..#$#"/$T(#:,(/-0K%(/(54-(-45%4(,4-F3/#$4-)(`?%(,&-(H3/'H&%(EK( ") D4$(?%(4-H43$(&$$(.;%#$K(,K34$(,45(H:,E:-4-$4-(T-..#$#"/$T(:'<(-F$$&-(&>( B")( OH -')$4=&%'"9#9*7J=%$%3'8K*'>%)7%G>*&%'&%'<=>G'1&G)&9&%5&9'01'&%&*3$8<*B*"=%$%3&%'$' 5&11&9L2M88&=91K4'P>6' &) ") P434>&-$&(H%/$4%/4%S(8/330?-03/0<4$J("40%/E3/0<4$J(3?#"&%<4$J(-F$$&( "S

24 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) o +Y44EM.@-H$/:-4-(,433&-(:3/H&($FE4%(&>(.;%"%@H-/-0(/(H@%>:%-&(?%(3?$$(&$$(.;%#$K(%434>&-#4-(&>)(D4$(?%($%:3/04-(>?%54.@33$(&$$(.K( %45&(EK($:$&3.;%"%@H-/-04-(:'<(<@%(,F'H4$(&>(54--&(#:,( "4#$K%(&>(43(:'<(&>(@EE>?%,-/-0)(D4$(?%(5:'H(/-$4(#G?3>H3&%$(&$$(,&-(.;%#$K%(&$$(#Y44EM.@-H$/:-4-(./--#(:'<(,&-(H&-(5?%.;%(,/##&(@EE543-/-04-(&>(.;%"%@H-/-04-)(( o P43&$/:-(,433&-(,4-F>&3(:'<(H@%>:%( o \@%>:%-&(R("4-?,-/-0(&>(&d3&%(:'<(#H&3:%)(Z&%H4-(dM(4334%(FM &d43-(<&%(-k0:-(4$/h4$$)(f>4-(:,(&->?-5&%4-($%:3/04-(h&-( 0/##&(#/0($/33(&$$(FM&d43-(>/#&%(Hh<J(#K(?%(54$$&(?%(/-$4(@EE4-"&%$)( bm&d43-#(e3&'4%/-0(?%(h:-$%&m/-$@/$/>j(4.$4%#:,(54(.34#$&( E4%#:-4%(<&%(4-(>&-&(&>(&$$(FM&d43-(E3&'4%&#($/33(>?-#$4%(:'<( /-$4($/33(<;04%)(O45&-(FM&d43-(>/#&%(Hh<(EK(&33&(,4-F>&3(?-5%&#( dm&d43-#($fe(&>(>?%54-(04-:,(#h/.$-/-04-)(8/,m>f-(>/#&%( $%:3/04-(/--4>&%&-54($/,,4(:'<(EK(dM&d43-(>/#&#(,/-@$4%(#:,( <&%(0K$$(@-54%(54--&($/,,4)(9?%(";%(,&-(H@--&(3:H&3/#4%&(#/0(/( &->?-5&%4(.;%>?-$&#(.;%#$K(H@%>&-(4.$4%(&$$(,&-(<&%(0%&-#H&$( 54-(@-54%(-K0%&(,/-@$4%)(i,(,&-("4<K334%("/354-(4-(#$@-5(#4%(,&-(:'H#K(<@%(54-(.;%?-5%&#)(( o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d3&%(0;%&#)(2((@EE#H&3-/-0( &>(H@%>:%-&(";%(,&-(>/5$&(K$0?%54%(#K(&$$(54(/-$4(H%F,E#(/<:E(.;%(,F'H4$(EK( "4H:#$-&5(&>($F53/0<4$4-)( QH -')$4=&%'"9#9*7J=%$%3'4&G&*'>%)7%G>*&%#'<=>G&'1&G)&9&%5&9'9$44'1$%#=>G' &%&*3$8<*B*"=%$%3'$'5&11&9L'2M88&=91K4'PB6' &) Z/3H&(543&%(/(0%?-##-/$$4$(?%(&>0;%&-54(.;%(&$$(,K34$(#H&(@EE-K#e( +&,,&(543&%(#:,(.;%(L..4H$,K3(B&)(( ") 9@%(>?3(#$;5G4%(54##&(543&%(,K34$(,45(&>#44-54(EK(#E4'/./'4%&54(H%/$4%/4%e( "T

25 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) ( P434>&-$&(H%/$4%/4%S(8/330?-03/0<4$J("40%/E3/0<4$J(3?#"&%<4$J(-F$$&( ') +3@$#&$#4%(:'<(H:,,4-$&%4%S(D4--&(.%K0&(?%(H:,E34d(:'<(H&-(/-$4("4#>&%&#(,45(4-(-:%,&3(&->?-5"&%<4$#@$>?%54%/-0)(D4-("4%;%(.&H$:%4%(#:,(.;%@$:,( 54#/0-4-(&>(#G?3>&(&EE4-#(.@-H$/:-4%(:'<(0%?-##-/$$(<&%(,45(&->?-5&%4-#(:'<( &->?-5-/-04-#(#&,,&-<&-0(&$$(0;%&)(L-(3?-0%4($/5#(&->?-5-/-0(";%(#$@54%&#( Slutsatser Expertutvärdering _004(9U(54'%(-@4<M%($E6,%59%0%($%0+,%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6%(1$%,,%03%5E,- <'U,-03%'+8MZ1#)%1/;</(@01+(%(CHU'<E'3%5E,-(700+;<4@0+'(495%((45%.-+,$E6C )@+,31(401+(,%55%(<%%5342@-+,4(9U(54'%(@4(<M<'M(@+,8+(%(0%'(4 E66'%')$%(+2$[O0%)&.39'%$(<E'/0-%-400%<<%@0,M.%0-@4/88(M--+,$E6CF( '%-%'9401+(U'5+2@40091-/%..6%-04.0(1(649<E'3'/@(1(61@/'9+'+2$-1<<'+'1(0%.U,84' -16<E' %'494(9U(54'%C&)#*U''%.40190%(@%.4004(9U(54Cd1--45%.4'3%$E9%' 5+2@%(6%(+,4'3%045-0'40%61<E'9455%-@4<E',%5.4A<E'91.@4+2$6E'45%0048M%00 8% @0-U00CGE'5%04.D%'A-%'%-/.040%0<'M(%Q8%'0/09U'5%'1(6%(C H%0U'91@ %<+',/.%'45%%<<%@0,M.%(8'%21-%'4-Cd451((%3U'0%QB400<E'-0M-1( %(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6BfWM.%(3%$E9%'<E' &)#*-8%21<1@049-%'400/(5%'.U004 <E'4(9U(54'(4Cd45<E'9U(04-4(9U(54'(44(9U(541(<+',401+(%(\M0%'@+88.1(6%(01..f GM'5%-94'8M0%Q+,91.@4$4(5.1(64'1$/-$M..%0-+,$4'.% <<'+'(4\6'4<%'(4f) -M<4..A<M'5%01..'U2@.161(<+',401+(<E'400@/((4<E'U(5'4-1003%0%%(5%fWM.%0B045%. 495%0%6(4$/-$M..%0-,+,%(04(4%(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6B-@/..%+2@-M@/((4/00'72@4-,%' 8'%21-0A0%Q10%',%'499455%01((%3U'400$&)6-")&95%0%6(4$/-$M..%0-,+,%(04(4 %(%'61<E'3'/@(1(6C K./0.16%(3E'8M8%@ @401+(%(/0%-./0%'-7(-@4545%4(9U(54'%-M9U.-+, 4(9U(54'%-+,49(M6+(4(.%5(1(61(0%@4(4(9U(54%(8%@-@U',CH%--/0+,3E' 6'U(--(100%0-%-0%01@@/((4<E'3U00'4-49-%9U'0CF(@+,,%'-1%..9154'%/09%2@.1(649 8'+0+078%(3E'6E'4-1-4,9%'@4(,%58'+<%--1+(%..44(9U(534'$%0-5%-16(%'-C Intervjuer med testanvändare Metodik )(0%'9D/%',%50%-04(9U(54'%6D+'5%-8M/885'4649)WX&<E'400<M%(31.549$/'5% /88.%95%4(9U(5(1(6%(49&)#*;488%(C)(0%'42019%)(-010/0%-@/..%<M045%.49488%(A,%(8641( (-8'+3.%,495%((48M1V$+(%<12@1(0%'9D/4'%(1(0% %(1((4( $+(6%(+,<E'5%1(0%'9D/%'(4C)(0%'9D/6/15%<E'<40045%-A)WX&'%@'70%'45% "b

26 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 0%-04(9U(54'%+2$1(0%'9D/%'6%(+,<E'5%-/(5%'"5464'1(+9%,3%'">PPC K4,,4(-0U..(1(649'%-/.040%091-4-(%54(C 017+$9#1"/$1#' 34'(8MPi'%-8"PM'[C -2%(4'3%04'%Z-+(01..1(<+',4(0('"[C R/,$&"/$)14' ZW[CW$4'3%'U0040+,488%(<E'-1(46'4((4'-+,$4' (0'%--%'45%494005%.04C (40/'%(C (:*/1' @+(0'+..%'Cd1--4M06U'5%'Z0C%QC1-+.%'1(649<E(-0%'[6D+'5%-$E-0%(">P>CYM6+03U00'% $4'5% C */-%($4'6+.99U',%+2$9U',-/88,%5<DU''9U',%C )(0%'9D/6/15%(<1(( PC S$+T/;:$' 1(0%'9D/%'6%(+,<E'5%-"T;"b(+9%,3%'">PPC Y%54(8'%-%(0%'4--4,,4(-0U..(1(64'<'M(1(0%'9D/%'(4C#%,4($4'15%(01<%'40-+2$ -4,,4(-0U (0%'9D/4'%(C "g

27 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) "#$%&#$''&()*%)+,-.& HA'7I$*"A/3*/'+TK',+1"$+33'I%/$'/37I$J$:,1)14/1' (78'+5/2%'45%$/-CH%03+'5%.1664.U6'%1(78'+5/2%'45%$/-CBYM6+0U'1(0%3'4BVM D.*/'(/#)*'2$%*'\(O1*#/'(0=%"%Q/*1*,$*W( "'"/,1),)1"$/**/' /0+%1.#.$.2-+& )VPd1..%-%6'4<%(CK1<<'+'-U6%',161(6%0A/04(945U',%5%.04.%0+2$-%54(-%$/' "J

28 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 3)4$2.&"56&78.,#$".& 5M,%5<DU''9U',%(rp460'+55%4005%094'0+04.%.%(A,%(5%091-45%-165M @+,<+'043%.0400$494',0BC A) *) 2-.:%,&-$4%-&#(.;%>?-$-/-0&%(( B) 8'%21-%'45%--+,e "i

29 "#$%&''(%$)*+%)'%(,-.$/)0%--1)2$)3(4-5) 7289(>4%H$F0(.;%(&$$(.K(H:-$%:33(;>4%(>&5(43%?H-/-04-(>/#&%(#:,(H:#$-&54%( -7(0%-0' %U((/1(0%94'1,8.%,%(0%'45%C Slutord "I