Progressreport and Problems in Building a Meassure Database for Sweden. Jens Mentzer Skagerak/Kattegat Water District Authority

Transkript

1 Progressreport and Problems in Building a Meassure Database for Sweden Jens Mentzer Skagerak/Kattegat Water District Authority

2 Definitions Meassure type: A standardized type of meassure or group of meassures e.g. fish migrating path-artificial migrating path-fish ladder Meassure: Physical/technical meassures in a specific place and time Policy instrument: instruments suggested in the PoM in order to make the meassures happening Meassure library: A list of meassure types, connected to certain attributes like costs, effects, relevant impacts and pressures. Meassure module: The reporting module for meassures (not policy instruments). Divided into suggested, planned, on going and completed.

3 The Module connects the Library (incl. meassure attributes) with reported actual meassures, according to meassure type Meassures today National databases VISS Meassure Module County, companies etc. etc. Meassure Library planning Data for policy analysis Reporting PoM Reporting EU Map Prioritizing Public participation Suggestion box Meassure potential Cost estimates Effect Estimates Other use

4 The idea By creating standard meassure types for physical measures, it will be the possible to load the meassure types with attributes needed for analysing, policy analysis, reporting of the PoMs and to the Commission etc. The meassure types is gathered in a library that is updated by the Water District Authorities.

5 Demo!!!

6 Challenges The development of the meassure library and meassure (reporting) module has been developed ahead of the actual development of the PoM and everything else EU reporting variables are not finalized and interim reporting variables are not really effects

7 Challenges Integration of measures reported in other databases Not orientated to meassure and no possibilities to fit into our meassure types (supervision) Not enough meassure for the WFD (Liming) Lack of information about the meassure (contaminated sites) No or different geographical reference i.e. waterbody (agriculture subsidices) Different defintion than WFD, like the costs (all)

8 Challenges In-house work on the library meant time but knowledge building What to include and what is better handled elsewhere, like basic/suplementary meassures WFD language, economic language, science language, laymen language (farmers, citizens etc.)

9 How detailed should the meassure type be? The need in different stages in the process, i.e. planned, on-going, completed, reported. The hierarcy of meassure types The integration of meassures from other meassure databases, with other objectives than WFD. RESULT: Three-level hierarcy adjusted to other databases.

10 What is an effect of a physical/technical meassure? If a meassure is completed or not? The unit of size (reporting unit) A reduction of a pollutant? In the air or in water? A standardized effect per impact comparable between meassures (cost-effeciency, i.e. kg Tot P)? The effect on the classification criteria e.g. ecological status EU interim reporting indicators? RESULT: Interim indicators, standardized effects, other effects and of course a unit of size

11 What is a cost of a physical/technical meassure? Investment cost? Total costs during the lifespan of the meassure? Discounted to year 0? What is year 0? Losses in production? Include administrative costs (private time, permit processing time)? Available cost estimates differs? RESULT: Investment, running, administrative, value/cost in final year, production losses

12 How should the meassure be presented in geography Consideration about privacy Suggested/planned meassures, not communicated with the stakeholders Planned meassures in a watersheed, but not yet to a certain waterbody RESULT: Suggested: not at all Planned: on watersheed, On-going/completed: waterbody, pressure, cordinates?

13 VISION: Present measures per water body Contamination mst Typ av åtgärd Punktkälla_id Åtgärd_id År Kostnad Effekt Efterbehandling A EBH_id_ Sanerat, miljögifter minskar Efterbehandling B Sanerat, miljögifter minskar Efterbehandling C Fysiska förändringar omst Typ av åtgärd Punktkälla_id Åtgärd_id År Kostnad Effekt Fisktrappa A Åtg_vatten_ Vandringshinder reducerat Fisktrappa B Vandringshinder reducerat Fisktrappa C

14 VISION: Present meausures by drainage area (information from VISS per waterbody through OpenAPI) Pågående Planerade Ytterligare 0 Förorenade områden Vandringshinder

15 Building for change

16 Future Feedback period for Meassure library in okt-nov An operational library in nov 2012 Module building, testing and released okt-feb Integration of meassures from the primary five databases in feb 2013 Reporting of suggested meassures from app. 20 counties in mars 2013 An updated second version of the library in 2013? A updated third version of the library in 2018

17 Thank you!

18 SM HI? SJV? LST? KUR anlagda Våtmarker SMP UTIS Miljöstöd Jordbruk SJV/LST Artportalen Artdata banken LOVA Eko-data LONA Eko-data NV Värdefulla Vatten NV ÖVISS MSB Vic Natur NV Nitratkänsliga Musselvatten Områden SJV Lst O EU rapportering Distrikt / VF KEMKoll Miljöreda EBH Eko-data? Measures VISS ÅP underlag HARO / VF Internationella Rapporteringar SoE, HELCOM, OSPAR mm Prio damm Kling Miljöboken SMHI Damm reg Kalk Eko-data Åtg. i Vatten Eko-data Biotop kart Bearbetning Av data NV Miljödata portalen MÖV meta data Badplatsen SMI TFV VHI SMHI SVAR/SHARK TFV Salt db DGV SGU Näringsämnes Belastnings Modeller Script som genererar Automat klassningar På VF a la Norge/Finland SLU/FiV Artportalen mussel IVL SMHI SGU LST Legend Underlags db Version Åtg db Mät data Skydd omr Diffus Försurnings Belastning MATCH SGU LMV kartdata kartdata Vattenföring SMHI kommuner

19 Example hydromorphology Measure Module Measure Library Biotope Assesment database Biotope Measures database Road culverts database Dams database Waterbody Type of measure Pressure_ID Measure_ID Year Cost (Euro) Effect 1 Fishladder A Bio_Meas_ID Improved continuity 1 Fishladder B Improved continuity 1 Fishladder C A B C

20 Measures Library Aim: Provide support to desk officers at county administration boards and municipalities when planning measures/mitigating environmental problems in water bodies. Provide an overview of costs and effects for desk officers, researchers and the public Quantifying the economic and environmental consequences of measures required by WFD

21 Webb-based measure library Estimated costs & effects (schabloner) Intervalls for costs and effects Connection to primary database Each measure type connected to Environmental problem Impacts Pressure Reporting unit one if possible but as many as needed

22 Additional support material stöddokument Extended/more in-depth description of measure Information about where the measure is suitable and where it is not suitable (locational limitations) More in-depth description of costs More in-depth description of effects Climate change perspective: how does the measure stand in a changing climate? How is the effect affected by increased temperature, more/less percipitation etc.? Downloadable excel files/equations for costs & effects

23 Conclusions Build for the future involve other sectors make it a daily Decision Support System. Aim waterbody level Make it easy to register initially Engage other database owners early in the process Anyone should be able to add measure as suggestions! Interaction with other databases initially by versioned imports later on live connections.

24 Detaljerad åtgärdstyp Huvudåtgärdstyp Åtgärdsbibliotek innehåll (exkl stöddokument) Beskrivning (åtgärdstyp) ÅtgärdstypID Sektor Geografisk redovisning i VISS Åtgärdspotential (GIS-filer i nationell lagring) Uppföljning av genomförda åtgärder (GIS-fil i lst nationella lagring?) Miljöpåverkan/ källa Miljöproblem/Impact som åtgärden påverkar Pressures /påverkanskällor av åtgärdstypen Berörda nationella miljömål Berörda nationella miljömålsindikatorer Rapporteringsenhet i modulen (ger schablonerna) Livslängd (år) Totala kostnader och intäkter per rapporteringsenhet för hela livslängden Antaganden och förutsättningar (för alla kostnader) Intervall Investeringskostnad per rapporteringsenhet Utredningskostnad Restvärde per rapporteringsenhet Löpande kostnad per rapporteringsenhet och år Löpande intäkter per rapporteringsenhet och år Löpande produktionsbortfall per rapporteringsenhet och år Miljöeffekter som ska redovisas per åtgärd vid rapportering i modulen EU:s miljöeffekt- indikatorer (Key measures - indicators) Miljöeffekt 1 Schabloneffekt per rapporteringsenhet Miljöeffekt 1 intervall Miljöeffekt 1 Beskrivning och antagande för schablonen Miljöeffekt 2 Schabloneffekt per rapporteringsenhet Miljöeffekt 2 intervall Miljöeffekt 2 Beskrivning och ev. antagande för schablonen Miljöeffekt 3 Schabloneffekt per rapporteringsenhet Miljöeffekt 3 intervall Miljöeffekt 3 Beskrivning och ev. antagande för schablonen Miljöeffekt 4 schablon Miljöeffekt 4 intervall Miljöeffekt 4 Beskrivning och ev. antagande för schablonen Fler miljöeffekter Miljöeffekter Beskrivning fritext Kostnadseffektivitet Exempel på synergieffekter Exempel på samverkansparter Exempel på finansieringskällor Exempel på hinder Åtgärdens lämplighet i ett förändrat klimat